It's common to see a student's ARM percentile and ISIP percentile land in different places, even when both are pulled from the same assessment window. This isn't a data error, it's the expected result of comparing two scores that are built differently.
The short answer
Two things drive the difference:
- The norms come from different years. ISIP percentile ranks are based on norms last updated in 2019. ARM norms are updated annually.
- The scores use different inputs. The Oral Reading Fluency (ORF) passage subscore (WCPM) contributes to the ARM score, but it does not contribute to the ISIP Overall Score.
Because the two scores are built from different norms and different measures, their percentiles aren't expected to line up, and a mismatch between them doesn't mean something is wrong with either score.
A closer look at each score
| ARM (Amira Reading Mastery) | ISIP | |
|---|---|---|
| What it shows | A Grade Level Equivalent (GLE) norm-referenced score showing how a student's performance compares to peers in the same grade. | A points-based score (100 to 900 scale) showing growth compared to national peers on the ISIP scale |
| Purpose | A complete view of reading mastery, compared to peers nationwide | A steady growth measure that gives continuity for schools that previously used Istation |
| What feeds into it | Multiple data sources, with emphasis on Oral Reading Fluency (WCPM) | A composite of legacy ISIP tasks, does not include Oral Reading Fluency |
| Norming | Updated annually | Last normed in 2019 |
Why this matters
Because ARM factors in Oral Reading Fluency and ISIP doesn't, a student who reads with strong fluency but is still developing in other tested skills (or vice versa) can score noticeably differently on the two measures. Add in the fact that ARM's norms reflect more recent student performance data while ISIP's norms are several years old, and some divergence between the two percentiles is expected, not a sign of an error.
What this means for interpretation
- Use ARM when you want an up-to-date, fluency-informed picture of a student's reading mastery relative to national peers.
- Use ISIP when you want continuity with historical Istation-based reporting and growth tracking.
- Don't expect the two percentiles to match. They're designed to answer related but different questions, using different inputs and different norming years.
For a visual side-by-side comparison of how each score is calculated, see Understanding ARM and ISIP Scores.